Ti West is a film-maker that you can count on. He loves to place characterisation first, and when making horror movies, this ensures you care about the characters. He loves to play it old school too, and never needs to cheat when developing his scares, like when some directors have things jump from just out of shot when the characters would have been able to see them already. The Innkeepers ticks all the right boxes.
Claire (Sara Paxton) and Luke (Pat Healy) are the two remaining employees of a hotel about to be shut down - the Yankee Pedlar Inn, reported site of Madeline O'Malley's suicide in the 1800s after her husband abandoned her on their wedding day. Both ghost hunting enthusiasts, they spend their last few days trying to contact O'Malley's spirit with only a couple of guests still staying in the inn. Unexpectedly, Claire begins to yield some results when the piano starts playing itself at night, but a clairvoyant guest warns her to steer clear of the basement where they supposedly stashed Madeline's body to save the reputation of the inn. Naturally, the haunting builds in intensity, and when something happens to one of the two remaining guests, it all spirals out of control culminating in a trip to the very same basement that they were warned about so vehemently...
Kudos must go to Eliot Rocket the cinematographer, whose camera swoops and dollies energetically to create some properly thrilling moments, almost like an action-horror hybrid. Sara Paxton too does a brilliantly natural job as Claire - we care about her as a character because she seems genuinely likeable and curious, and always eager to help out her mate Luke. The cast are helped by West's very flowing dialogue, which builds from light-hearted comedy in the first half to some intense arguments throughout the second. Final props must go to Jeff Grace, the composer. From the opening strings over the credits to the eerie piano rolls throughout the initial haunting and the final orchestra explosion, the 'avant-garde' musician nails the tone of the film beautifully.
Here's what Esteban had to say about this 2011 effort:
I want to tell you of a story of a family I once be haved in. It was many a year ago, back in my hometown of Peru. We once went on a holiday, and walked to the next village to enjoy the lovely tree and coffee beans. We stayed inside an inn. In the in we were staying in was a man who had grey hair and overalls. He would carry bread roll in his pockets which was a scary theme. The story is about this because he still was not as scary as the movie film which was pretty scary in my frankly opinion. My least favourite part was when the character drank the beer. Thank you.
Okay, so some modern viewers may consider the film a little generic or even a little slow - but I liked that about it. It's an homage to earlier days of horror when gore wasn't the first priority, and it serves this purpose pretty well. As always, I hope the West can return to this form after the slight misstep that was his segment in V/H/S - I'm giving it 3 out of 4 hanged brides.